Lauren Ellis (Fiction) Erin Davis (Fiction) Sara Lance (Legends of Tomorrow) Mazikeen (Lucifer) WINNER Linda Martin (Lucifer) Chloe Decker (Lucifer) Lauren Strucker (The Gifted)
Male Character:
Lucifer Morningstar (Lucifer) Amenadiel (Lucifer) Mick Rory (Legends of Tomorrow) WINNER Andy Strucker (The Gifted)
** John Constantine omitted because he won March.
Guest Star:
Abraxis [Fairy Godmother] (Legends) WINNER Dr Natalie Hastings (Fiction)
Couple:
John & Sara (Legends of Tomorrow) WINNER BY DEFAULT
Team:
Lucifer & Amenadiel [siblings] (Lucifer) Lauren & Erin [friends] (Fiction) Mazikeen & Lucifer [friends] (Lucifer) WINNER Mick & John [team mates] (Legends) Andy & Lauren [siblings] (The Gifted)
Sara Lance [white canary] (Legends of Tomorrow) WINNER Mick Rory [heat wave] (Legends of Tomorrow) Andy Strucker [mutant] (The Gifted) Lauren Strucker [mutant] (The Gifted)
** John Constantine omitted as he won March.
Best Story:
Sisterly Advice [Lauren Ellis & Erin Davis] (Fiction) Unicorn Dust and a Godmother From Hell [Sara Lance, John Constantine, Mick Rory] (Legends) WINNER Saints and Sinners Come Together [Lucifer, Linda, Mazikeen & Chloe] (Lucifer) We Have A Gift [Andy, Lauren, Caitlin & Reed] (The Gifted)
Best Scene:
1) Sara getting ready to kill John with the glass slipper [Unicorn Dust & A Godmother From Hell] (Legends of Tomorrow)
2) John sending Abraxis (Godmother) back to hell through the ring of fire portal [Unicorn Dust & A Godmother From Hell] (Legends of Tomorrow)
3) John and Sara admitting secret feelings for one another and kissing. [Unicorn Dust and A Godmother Frm Hell] (Legends of Tomorrow) WINNER
4) Mick's awkward entrance as John and Sara are getting hot and heavy with one another. [Unicorn Dust and a Godmother From Hell] (Legends)
5) Andy sitting hunched up, after destroying the school boys toilets when his powers manifested through fear. [We Have A Gift] (The Gifted)
6) Maze cracking up and pointing, doubled over laughing at the snort that comes out of Chloe's mouth. [Saints and Sinners Come Together] (Lucifer)
Best Quote:
1) Lucifer to Amenadiel [Father Says] (Lucifer)
“So you aren't going to keep pushing me to try and change my mind? Who are you and what have you done with my brother?”
2) John to Sara [Unicorn Dust and a Godmother From Hell] (Legends of Tomorrow)
“Aye love, I feel ready for the fight. Let's go catch us a demon unicorn and fairy godmother.”
3) Sara to John [Unicorn Dust & A Godmother From Hell] (Legends of Tomorrow)
“You start calling me Cinders and I swear I'll punch you in the face.”
4) Sara to John [Unicorn Dust and a Godmother From Hell] (Legends of Tomorrow)
“Well, all I can say is, it sort of gives Disney a bad name really. Killed by a glass slipper.”
5) John to Sara [Unicorn Dust and a Godmother From Hell] (Legends of Tomorrow)
“That is very true you know. Can just see the headlines now. Man killed by a Cinderella with her glass slipper. Disney outraged. Seeking the female in question to hang her out to dry for giving them a bad name.”
6) Lucifer to Linda [Saints and Sinners Come Together] (Lucifer)
“Because some bumps just happen to be hills. I think that was more of a hill that morning.”
7) Mick to John and Sara [Unicorn Dust and a Godmother From Hell] (Legends of Tomorrow)
“Looks like Cinders found her Prince Charming. What a sight to see.”
8) Mick to John (with reference to the demon trying to get Sara to kill him with the glass slipper) [Unicorn Dust and a Godmother From Hell] (Legends of Tomorrow)
“I see she didn't quite manage it, pity.”
9) Lucifer to Maze [Saints and Sinners Come Together] (Lucifer) WINNER
“Dear me Maze, everyone has a little bit of the devil in them, didn't you know that?”
10) Maze to Lucifer [Saints and Sinners Come Together] (Lucifer)
“I suppose so, I mean I've seen some humans being bad ass, then again, you've had your wicked way with a lot of the women, so I guess everyone having a bit of a devil in them isn't so outrageous a thought.”
11) Maze to Chloe [Saints and Sinners Come Together] (Lucifer)
“I'm a sinner because I'm a very very naughty girl. I do things that would even shame the devil himself.”
